InboxGreen vs MXToolbox

Which tool is right for fixing emails going to spam?

Short answer: MXToolbox is a powerful multi-tool for network engineers. InboxGreen is built specifically for business owners who want to fix SPF, DKIM, and DMARC fast - with copy-paste DNS records and plain-English guidance. If you are not an IT professional, InboxGreen gets you to the fix faster.

MXToolbox

Network diagnostics suite

Blacklist check, email headers, DNS lookup, routing, ping, traceroute, and more. Complex. Designed for IT pros.

Free tier (limited lookups/day)

Paid from ~$129/mo

InboxGreen

Email deliverability fix kit

SPF/DKIM/DMARC check, copy-paste DNS records for Cloudflare, Namecheap, Google Workspace and more. Built for non-technical users.

Free check (no account needed)

FixKit $29 one-time · Monitor from $19/mo

Feature comparison

Feature InboxGreen MXToolbox
Free SPF / DKIM / DMARC check Yes - no account required Yes (limited free lookups)
Copy-paste DNS records (Cloudflare, Namecheap...) Yes - formatted per registrar No
Plain-English fix guidance Yes Technical output only
DMARC monitoring + alerts Yes - from $19/mo Yes - from ~$129/mo
Blacklist checker Free - try it Yes (free tier)
SPF record generator Free - try it Yes (limited)
DMARC record generator Free - try it No generator
Email header analyzer Free - try it Yes
Network tools (ping, traceroute, BGP) No Yes - extensive
SMTP diagnostics Limited Yes - SMTP test
White-label PDF reports Yes - Agency plan $99/mo Not available
One-time payment option Yes - FixKit $29 Subscription only
Designed for small businesses Yes Primarily IT/enterprise

When to use MXToolbox

  • You need network diagnostics (ping, traceroute, BGP routing).
  • You're an IT professional managing mail servers and infrastructure.
  • You need SMTP testing beyond just DNS record validation.
  • You're diagnosing complex routing or IP reputation issues at scale.

When to use InboxGreen

  • You run a small business and your emails are going to spam.
  • You need copy-paste DNS records you can actually add to Cloudflare or Namecheap.
  • You don't know what SPF, DKIM, or DMARC means but need them fixed.
  • You want email alerts when your DNS records break, without paying $129/month.
  • You manage email for multiple clients and need white-label deliverability reports.

Pricing comparison

MXToolbox's free tier is useful for occasional lookups, but monitoring and alerting require a paid plan starting at around $129/month for the Standard plan. That covers one monitored domain with email alerts.

InboxGreen is significantly cheaper for the same core use case:

  • Free: Full SPF/DKIM/DMARC check, blacklist check, 8 free tools - no account needed.
  • FixKit ($29 one-time): Copy-paste DNS records formatted for your registrar + PDF guide. No subscription.
  • Monitoring ($19/month): Daily checks, email alerts when records change or fail, up to 5 domains.
  • Agency ($99/month): Up to 30 domains, white-label PDF reports for clients.

If you only need a one-time fix, InboxGreen's $29 FixKit gets you there without any ongoing cost.

Try InboxGreen free - no account needed.
Check your domain's SPF, DKIM and DMARC in seconds and see exactly what needs to be fixed.

Frequently asked questions

Is MXToolbox free?

MXToolbox has a free tier that covers basic lookups (blacklist check, MX lookup, SPF check) with daily limits. Features like continuous monitoring, email alerts, and uptime tracking require a paid subscription starting around $129/month.

Can MXToolbox fix my emails going to spam?

MXToolbox can diagnose whether your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are present and valid, but it does not generate ready-to-use fix records or explain what to do next in plain language. You'll still need to figure out the correct DNS records yourself. InboxGreen's FixKit generates the exact records you need, formatted for your specific DNS provider.

Does InboxGreen replace MXToolbox?

Not for network diagnostics. If you need to test SMTP servers, run traceroutes, or diagnose IP routing, MXToolbox has tools InboxGreen does not. For the core job of checking and fixing email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), InboxGreen is more focused and more affordable.

What is the cheapest way to monitor DMARC?

InboxGreen's Monitoring plan at $19/month covers daily DMARC, SPF, and DKIM checks with email alerts for up to 5 domains - making it one of the most affordable options compared to MXToolbox (~$129/mo) or EasyDMARC (~$18-45/mo).